Game On (Into Darkness, Book 3), by Navessa Allen | Free Audiobook
30 March 2026
Train Dreams, by Denis Johnson | Free Audiobook
30 March 2026
Audiobook details
The creature had the better argument
Victor Frankenstein is a young student at the University of Ingolstadt when he crosses the line nobody else dared to approach. He has spent years reading everything, questioning everything, and deciding that the boundary between life and death is a problem worth solving. One November night, the body on his table opens its yellow eyes. Victor runs. That decision shapes everything that follows.
The creature he leaves behind has no name, no history, and no one. He finds shelter at the edge of a forest, watches a family through the seasons, teaches himself to read, and builds up a store of hope that the book then carefully dismantles. When he finally speaks, the most articulate character in the novel turns out to be the one Mary Shelley never gave a name. His account of what was done to him is impossible to argue with. Victor tries anyway.
This BBC Radio production, first broadcast in November 2012 and dramatized by Lucy Catherine, stages the story as a series of nested confessions: Walton writing to his sister, Victor narrating to Walton, the creature speaking to Victor. The structure keeps the question open throughout. Every version of events is someone's version, and the cold geography of the action, from Geneva to the Arctic, matches the temperature of what the characters refuse to say to each other directly.
I went in expecting the monster. The monster is not the problem. Victor Frankenstein is the problem, and this BBC production makes that unavoidable without once editorializing. Jamie Parker plays him not as a villain but as a man who never stops believing his own justifications. That is considerably worse.
Shaun Dooley's creature is the performance that stays with you. He has one extended speech where he lays out his case, catalogues what he was denied, and explains the logic of what followed. It is airtight. The production gives him space to make it, and Dooley delivers it without self-pity. You don't feel sorry for him. You recognize him.
The nested structure of the novel, letters inside confessions inside a frame narrative, is kept intact in Lucy Catherine's adaptation. The BBC production doesn't flatten it into a single point of view. You remain aware throughout that every version of events is filtered, which is the moral point Shelley was making in 1818 and which this production respects completely.
At under two hours, this is a tight adaptation. The creature's months of self-education in the forest are compressed, and those scenes lose a little of their weight. But the essential arc holds, and the sound design gives the arctic sequences a physical bleakness that pure narration cannot achieve. The cast understands that the worst things in gothic horror are described plainly. Nobody shouts. The restraint is exactly right.
If you have read the novel, this production adds something. If you haven't, it is a clean two-hour entry point to a book that has been simplified by its own cultural shadow. The original argument is sharper than the legend.
Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, first published in 1818, is staged here as a BBC Radio drama directed by Marc Beeby, with Lucy Catherine's adaptation and a cast led by Jamie Parker as Victor Frankenstein and Shaun Dooley as the Creature. The production ran on BBC Radio 4 in November 2012 and runs 1 hour and 54 minutes.
Hear Jamie Parker and Shaun Dooley split the moral weight of the novel between two performances that refuse to make it easy for the listener to choose a side. Your free trial gives you the full production at no cost. Cancel any time before the trial ends and pay nothing.
The audiobook remains yours forever, even after the trial ends. The free trial also gives you access to thousands of other titles, with no commitment. Start listening now.
US-based editor & staff writer focused on audiobooks. Honest reviews, curated “best of” lists, and practical guides with an accessibility lens.
