
Fletcher's Grove lives off visitors, and Emily Lane lives off the visitors' weakness for tinsel. Her shop, Under the Mistletoe, sells decorations in July and does well enough that nobody asks too many questions about the woman running it.
What she does with the rest of her time is the problem, in the nicest possible way: she investigates the murders that keep turning up in a town built on charm. This season brings three of them, and each one hides something unpleasant under a tradition, an old grudge, a convenient accident, a name that does not belong to the person using it. Meanwhile her connection with Detective Sam Wilner moves forward, and the closer the cases get to her own past, the less she can keep it out of the room.

Cozy crime has an obvious failure mode: the murder stops mattering because the setting is too pleasant. This series avoids it by making the town's charm the thing that hides the bodies.
Cobie Smulders has played Emily Lane for five seasons now, and the familiarity pays off: the character has a rhythm, a set of deflections and a stubborn streak, and you can hear the writing trust the performer with all three. Raymond Ablack's Sam Wilner is the right kind of foil, patient enough that his frustration lands when it finally shows.
Three hours and fifty-eight minutes, three mysteries, and a full cast rather than a single voice, plus the sound design the series is known for. Kylee Evans and Jean Yoon are among the returning ensemble, and the whole thing is produced to be listened to in the dark of a December evening, which is exactly the point.
Housekeeping: this is the fifth season, so there is a history behind the relationship that the story assumes you know, and it is exclusive to Audible, which is why there is one button here. It also has no ratings yet.
If the format is what you are after, Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel is another recent full-cast mystery, and The Stone Sisters takes family secrets into darker territory. This one is the lightest and the most seasonal of the three.
What I like most is that the cases are small in scale and personal in consequence. Nobody is saving the world here; somebody is lying about a name, and that turns out to be enough to get people killed. It is the audio equivalent of a very good Christmas film, and I mean that as praise rather than as a limit.
And a small thing that matters: the town is written with affection rather than with the usual wink, so the festive trimmings never turn into parody.
Mistletoe Murders 5 returns to Fletcher's Grove for a fifth season of the Audible Original: Emily Lane runs a Christmas shop all year and solves the murders that keep spoiling the postcard. Three cases this time, and a deepening partnership with Detective Sam Wilner. Three hours and fifty-eight minutes, with Cobie Smulders, Raymond Ablack and a full cast.
The trial works well for a series like this, because you can start at season five, hear the tone in a single sitting, and then decide whether you want to go backwards. Open the title, listen, and keep it if it catches you. If it does not, cancelling takes a couple of clicks and no explanation.
A guide on the cancellation process is available. And whatever you decide about the subscription, the audiobook stays yours. Before that, hang the stockings: four hours, and a town where the decorations are doing the lying.
Never miss a free audiobook
New releases and deals, straight to your inbox.