
Some people collect friends, and Teagan Townsend collects obsessions. She left college without finishing, she would rather spend an evening with a case file than with another human being, and the only thing she has built in years is a true crime podcast that nobody is listening to yet.
Her subject is Gods of Tomorrow, a band on the rise run by two brothers, Declan and Luca De Rossi, with a reputation that has nothing to do with the music: unsettling songs, followers who take things much too far, and a taste for blood that the stories insist is not a metaphor. Chaos trails them, people connected to them disappear or die, and the silence around it is the loudest thing about them. A backstage pass gets Teagan inside, where she intends to expose the whole thing and finds that seeing them clearly is much harder from close up.

I went into this expecting the usual rockstar fantasy with a body count bolted on. What I found is a book with a genuinely unpleasant protagonist in the best sense, and a band that stays unsettling instead of turning cuddly by chapter ten.
Teagan is the reason it works. She is obsessive, deliberately isolated and not remotely a good investigator, which makes her a far more interesting narrator than the competent journalist this story could have had. Elle Mitchell lets her be wrong about people, and lets the attraction to Declan and Luca pull her exactly where she said she would not go. The podcast framing gives the whole thing a documentary quality that keeps the tension up between the set pieces.
The three narrators make a real difference here. Autumn Mercer carries Teagan with a flat, slightly detached delivery that suits the character, and Ash Beverly and Ryan Stone give the brothers separate voices rather than the same low growl twice, which is not always the case in this subgenre. Ten hours and thirty six minutes is a good length for a duet opener.
My complaint is that the mystery thread resolves more conveniently than it deserves, and a couple of the band's hangers-on are indistinguishable from each other. It is the first half of a duet, so some threads are meant to stay open.
Content warning, and a real one: violence, drugs, and a relationship that is unhealthy in every direction. If that is what you came for, Vicious Prince has the same appetite with less music, and The Cannibal is the darker, colder version of the same idea.
What I did not expect was how much of the book is about fandom rather than romance. The band's following behaves exactly like the worst corners of any real fanbase, and Mitchell is clearly having fun with the fact that the obsessive podcaster and the obsessive fans are the same species.
Pretty Poisoned puts a true crime podcaster with a backstage pass in front of Gods of Tomorrow, a rock band run by two brothers with unsettling lyrics and a literal appetite for blood. Ten hours and thirty six minutes, narrated by Autumn Mercer, Ash Beverly and Ryan Stone.
The way to listen without paying is the free trial, and the mechanism is worth knowing: you sign up, you download the title, you cancel, and the book stays in your library permanently, exactly as if you had bought it. Nothing requires you to finish it during the trial, the file does not expire, and the only step that matters is the cancellation.
Ten and a half hours will get you through a week, and three narrators make the multiple perspectives easy to follow: playback resumes exactly where you stopped on any device, speed is adjustable and the sleep timer is there for late sessions.
Ten and a half hours is a good length for a duet opener, and the download means a long commute or a flight is covered.
Never miss a free audiobook
New releases and deals, straight to your inbox.