Sometimes I Scare Myself, by Jeneva Rose | Free Audiobook
Three familiar settings, and three endings nobody sees coming
Three stories, three settings everybody has seen before, and the promise that the endings will not be the ones you expect. A birthday dinner where a hired medium turns a party trick into something nobody can undo. A family that moves out of a city they no longer feel safe in, into a small town house with a history the neighbours do not mention. And a group of friends on their way to a cabin who ignore a hand-painted warning at a roadside store, because who would take that seriously.
Each story is long enough to build a full cast of people and then put them under pressure, which is the point of the format: these are not quick shocks but novellas, with the slow domestic detail that makes a horror story land harder when the floor finally gives way. The horror here is the patient kind, arriving through bad decisions made early and consequences that arrive late.
It is a collection rather than a novel, written by Jeneva Rose, whose thrillers have spent years on the bestseller lists, and the audio edition runs 9 hours and 37 minutes with a full cast of five narrators, including Kathleen Early, Brittany Pressley and Abigail Reno.
The first thing to know is structural, because it decides whether this book is for you: this is not one of those collections with fifteen quick stories you can dip into on a commute. It is three horror novellas, each long enough to build a full cast and then put them under pressure, and the format is the whole trick. A reviewer at Movies We Texted About put it exactly that way, saying they had expected 10 to 15 short stories that were a little creepy and got three horror tales that are basically novellas instead, before concluding that the choice gives the author room to explore a terrifying story without overplaying her hand.
The three setups are deliberately familiar. A thirtieth birthday dinner where a friend hires a medium as a joke and the joke does not stop when the medium dies. A family that leaves a city they no longer feel safe in for a small town house nobody warns them about. A group of friends driving to a winter cabin who ignore a hand-painted warning at a roadside store, because no reasonable person would take it seriously. Recognition is the point: you know what kind of story you are in, which is why the endings land the way they do.
What makes it work is patience. Jeneva Rose writes domestic detail extremely well, and the horror in these stories comes from the ordinary accumulation of bad decisions made early and consequences that arrive late, rather than from gore. The reviewer at Movies We Texted About, who gave it a perfect score, compared the endings to R.L. Stine and said the stories will leave you unsettled for days, which is about the highest compliment the genre has.
The fair caveat is the same one that made the reviewer hesitate: with only three stories, this is a shorter experience than the title suggests, and the audio runs 9 hours and 37 minutes across the whole collection. It is also an anthology with five narrators, including Kathleen Early, Brittany Pressley and Abigail Reno, so the voice changes between stories, which suits the format but means there is no single performance to settle into. If you liked Jeneva Rose's thrillers, another of hers is on the site: The Perfect Divorce.
Sometimes I Scare Myself is a horror collection from Jeneva Rose, the author behind The Perfect Marriage. Three stories, three settings you will recognise, and three sets of consequences nobody sees coming: a birthday dinner with a medium nobody should have invited, a family who moves into the wrong house in a small town, and a roadside stop where a warning is ignored.
These are novellas rather than quick shocks, each long enough to build a cast and then put them under real pressure, with the domestic detail that makes horror land harder. The result is the patient kind of scary, closer to an unsettling week than a jump scare.
It runs 9 hrs and 37 mins, read by a full cast of five narrators including Kathleen Early, Brittany Pressley and Abigail Reno. With the free trial, you can pick any title you want, this one included, cancel whenever you like, and the audiobook stays in your library after the trial ends.
Start your free trial, cancellable at any time
Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
More Horror Audiobooks
