The Deal (Off-Campus, Book 1), by Elle Kennedy | Free Audiobook
10 April 2026
Yesteryear, by Caro Claire Burke | Free Audiobook
12 April 2026
Audiobook details
He had one good thing and let it go before he knew it mattered
John Logan has the kind of life that looks, from the outside, like it is going exactly where it should. He is a junior at Briar University, one of the central players on a hockey team expected to go far, and known around campus for a casual ease that makes most things seem to come without effort. What he has not told anyone, including Garrett Graham, his closest friend, is that he has spent most of the year carrying feelings for Hannah Wells that have no future because Hannah is Garrett's girlfriend. Logan is doing his best to find a way out of that particular situation, and not finding one.
Grace Ivers is a freshman, the daughter of a Briar professor, and not remotely interested in Logan's reputation when he ends up in her room one evening by accident. What happens between them gets cut short by a decision Logan makes before he has worked out what Grace actually means to him. He tells her that he has been using the distraction she provided to get over Hannah. Grace does not stay to hear anything else. She goes to Paris for the summer, and Logan spends those months slowly understanding the difference between what he thought he felt for Hannah and what Grace had already started to be.
When both return to Briar in the fall, Grace has no interest in revisiting anything, and Logan has no intention of stopping. She gives him a list of things to accomplish before she will consider forgiving him. He works through every item. The Mistake is the second Off-Campus novel and follows John Logan rather than Garrett, though the two stories share the same campus, the same hockey house, and some of the same faces. It can be read on its own, though returning readers will find the familiar context adds something to Logan's half of the story.
The first Off-Campus book made Garrett easy to like. This one takes Logan, who exists in that book as the charming, slightly reckless best friend, and builds him a private life that complicates every surface reading of who he appears to be. The mistake he makes early in the story is not dramatized or softened. It is just wrong, and the book knows it.
Logan's situation at the start is more layered than the standard sports romance setup. He has been carrying feelings for Hannah Wells while knowing with complete clarity that acting on them would end his friendship with Garrett. He is not villainized for this. The book takes seriously the idea that you can feel something for someone in a context where that feeling has no good direction, and it uses Logan's awareness of his own situation to make the mistake he later makes with Grace feel like a failure of courage rather than of character. That distinction is what makes him worth following across ten hours.
Grace is the more straightforward of the two leads, which is not a criticism. She knows what she wants, processes Logan's error without extended hand-wringing, and returns from Paris having decided that her freshman year's worst decision does not get to define her sophomore year. Her willingness to eventually engage with Logan's effort comes from a specific place in her own history rather than from the plot needing it to happen. Elle Kennedy earns that shift.
Logan's family situation runs underneath the romance without taking it over. His father's alcoholism and the financial reality it created meant Logan had been quietly considering giving up hockey to work in the family shop. The scene where his father is found collapsed on the floor, on the exact day Logan had planned something important with Grace, is the moment where the book's two emotional threads cross cleanly. It is not melodramatic. It is just the kind of bad timing that makes everything harder to hold together.
Lorelei Avalon reads Grace's chapters with the same dry precision she brought to the first book. Lee Samuels handles Logan with a warmth that keeps you on his side even during the chapters where he is doing everything wrong. At 10 hours and 12 minutes, the dual narration gives each character's half of the story a distinct rhythm, and the difference between the two voices makes the eventual alignment feel like it was earned by both sides.
Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
The Mistake by Elle Kennedy is the second Off-Campus novel and follows John Logan, Garrett Graham's teammate and best friend, as he spends a semester trying to recover from a single bad decision. He met Grace Ivers, said exactly the wrong thing at exactly the wrong moment, and spent the summer that followed figuring out what he had actually lost. The book pairs a second-chance structure with a family situation that gives Logan's arc more weight than the campus romance setup would suggest.
Take advantage of the free trial, cancellable at any time, and hear Lorelei Avalon and Lee Samuels narrate all 10 hours and 12 minutes. Avalon's precision on Grace's chapters and Samuels' warmth on Logan's keep the two perspectives acoustically distinct, which matters across a story where each character is working through the same events from a different angle.
The audiobook remains yours forever, even after the trial ends. The free trial also gives you access to thousands of other titles at no ongoing cost. Start listening now.
More Audiobooks by Elle Kennedy
US-based editor & staff writer focused on audiobooks. Honest reviews, curated “best of” lists, and practical guides with an accessibility lens.
